2023-11-09 14:29:35
There's a lot wrong here. It's not a history lesson but based on Deuteronomy. The Bible is not a reliable historical source. It's possible Shai knows this because he didn't link to the Wikipedia article the map is from. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(53-12-119) Author
2023-11-09 16:32:27
NNN. It’s factually true. The specifics of it being deuteronomistic doesn’t mean that it’s false, that’s still a multiple thousand year old historical document, and the real kingdom of Israel and the ancient Israelites are not biblical in the true sense. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(71-8-28) Author
2023-11-09 18:22:39
There’s no modern humans descended only from ancient hebrews (AH), but there are: 1) Palestinian muslims primarily from AH + Africa. 2) Mizrahi jews primarily from AH + Europe. Before Ashkenazi (primarily Europe) jews colonized modern Israel, these groups lived in peace. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(14-1-86) Author
2023-11-09 21:27:14
This is based on history from a holy book (probably Deuteronomy), the accuracy of which is a matter of opinion but it is clearly the opinion of the poster that it is is correct. Arguments about religion belong in comments, but are probably a bad idea. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(21-4-29) Author
2023-11-10 01:21:24
When Muslims deny this claim, even their Qur'an confirms that what Deuteronium (5th book of Torah) says is correct. Qur'an further claims words (Torah) from Allah can't be changed. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(19-4-14) Author
2023-11-10 01:27:09
Assuming the Old Testament narrative is true, the claim of Jews being indigenous & not colonizers is invalid. To establish the kingdom of Israel and Judah the Jews (descended from Abraham of Ur in modern day Iraq) conquered the land under Joshua following Exodus [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(27-3-46) Author