2023-11-09 14:29:35
There's a lot wrong here. It's not a history lesson but based on Deuteronomy. The Bible is not a reliable historical source. It's possible Shai knows this because he didn't link to the Wikipedia article the map is from. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(7-1-25) Author
2023-11-09 16:32:27
NNN. It’s factually true. The specifics of it being deuteronomistic doesn’t mean that it’s false, that’s still a multiple thousand year old historical document, and the real kingdom of Israel and the ancient Israelites are not biblical in the true sense. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(12-1-4) Author
2023-11-09 17:56:41
1. Israel is sovereign nation and has right to exist 2. Making histrical claims such as OP is double edged sword and irrelevant 3. Claim that Jews indigenous group gives others same claim since even bible says that Jews came there from somewhere else [Link][Link] CURRENTLY_RATED_NOT_HELPFUL(1-1-9) Author
2023-11-09 18:22:39
There’s no modern humans descended only from ancient hebrews (AH), but there are: 1) Palestinian muslims primarily from AH + Africa. 2) Mizrahi jews primarily from AH + Europe. Before Ashkenazi (primarily Europe) jews colonized modern Israel, these groups lived in peace. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(3-0-16) Author
2023-11-09 21:27:14
This is based on history from a holy book (probably Deuteronomy), the accuracy of which is a matter of opinion but it is clearly the opinion of the poster that it is is correct. Arguments about religion belong in comments, but are probably a bad idea. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(4-0-3) Author
2023-11-10 01:21:24
When Muslims deny this claim, even their Qur'an confirms that what Deuteronium (5th book of Torah) says is correct. Qur'an further claims words (Torah) from Allah can't be changed. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(2-0-1) Author
2023-11-10 01:27:09
Assuming the Old Testament narrative is true, the claim of Jews being indigenous & not colonizers is invalid. To establish the kingdom of Israel and Judah the Jews (descended from Abraham of Ur in modern day Iraq) conquered the land under Joshua following Exodus [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(7-0-7) Author