2023-11-24 13:07:53
The footage shown has come from security cam footage, Hamas' own recorded footage from both go pros and videos they livestreamed It has previously been screened to journalists and members of various governments to bear witness to the atrocities carried out on Oct 7th by Hamas [Link][Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(20-1-37) Author
2023-11-24 13:21:46
The proposed note gives no actual information or comments about what has been said. It doesn't clarify or correct misleading statements. This is an opinion about who the videos should be shared with not about who it has already been viewed by. There is no contradiction NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(21-0-8) Author
2023-11-24 13:34:03
There’s strong debate in Israel whether to publish the footage. Mental health experts oppose it due to it being psychologically harmful to the traumatized public. [Link] In addition, the government said it wants to seek consent of families whose loved ones appear in the footage. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(15-4-27) Author
2023-11-24 14:01:31
It represents sincere opinion of its author and contains no controversial facts. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(19-0-7) Author
2023-11-24 14:02:46
Walker is from Novara Media, who can verify & report it independently if they chose to. They have chosen not to. The videos have already been verified as go pro footage from Hamas terrorists. His tweet is to sow seeds of doubt without evidence, for social media clicks. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(13-2-35) Author
2023-11-24 14:43:47
The original tweet does not provide any piece of evidence of what actually happened during the screening, or what is the content of the screening itself. Thus, the tweet is purely for internet clicks. Even though the screening raised controversy over the IDF claims: [Link] CURRENTLY_RATED_NOT_HELPFUL(10-1-40) Author
2023-11-24 17:20:14
NNN nothing in the notes provides anyth useful. IDF can show the footage and require its contents not being discussed. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(5-0-3) Author
2023-11-24 18:24:13
Nnn. The footage Giles is referring to has not been shared with the public, and showing the footage to journalists in a screening is not “verification”. Whether you think verification is necessary is a personal opinion you should keep to the comment section. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(15-1-4) Author