2024-08-24 03:09:50
There is no genetic test that can conclusively show somebody’s sex or gender[1]. Even if there was, such testing was not a requirement for participation in the 2024 Olympic boxing events[2], so this wouldn’t be relevant here [1]: [Link] [2]: [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(26-0-47) Author
2024-08-24 04:34:10
Colin Wright says both I. Khelif Lin You Ting are male which is a lie JK Rowling repeats the authors view that DNA determines sex, which is false [Link] Both boxers were born female, & have been accepted by the IOC as female. "Misinformation, abuse and injustice"; [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(41-0-59) Author
2024-08-24 06:09:32
NNN. This post is not misleading or false. If you have an XY chromosome, you are biologically male. It doesn't matter if you have differing body parts. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(25-0-23) Author
2024-08-24 08:01:20
NNN - It’s factually correct - the boxers have not provided test results. Rowling provides a link for context. OP is expressing an opinion about an issue where the science is not settled. Counter-arguments about test methods, classification, etc should be made in comments. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(23-0-19) Author
2024-08-24 08:54:58
The Conversation article cited in two Community Notes uses the term “intersex”, which is disputed by many people with DSDs and considered offensive. Also “intersex” does not invalidate the sex binary. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(13-4-9) Author
2024-08-25 20:51:31
NNN - true: Cio rules were not broken. But Rowling's opinion (2 agree or not in comments) is precisely to stress this as 1 of many bombing women's rights by using gender where sex should be. Cacholote ref. [1] does not refute DNA determines sex, says it's complex, + there's dsd. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(1-0-3) Author