2024-12-21 15:40:04
There is no evidence for the claim that the Magdeburg killer is a Shia-Muslim. The killer has an account on X with over 40.000 followers and thus his atheist and anti-Muslim mindset is well known. He was dissatisfied with German treatment of Saudi refugees. [Link][Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(144-6-173) Author
2024-12-21 15:45:59
NNN. She's expressing an opinion and is providing evidence. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(89-7-45) Author
2024-12-21 17:30:54
Maral is an Iranian ex-Muslim and Shia. She fits into the profile she is complaining about. The Magdeburg attacker is anti Islam and a far right supporter. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(108-2-168) Author
2024-12-21 18:12:18
She is offering an analysis with evidence as strong, as the evidence offered by EUs legacy media. Central in her analysis is the Islamic concept of taqiyya, which grants muslims the right to lie, when needed to advance in hostile environments. It seem very plausible. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(51-5-43) Author
2024-12-21 18:24:20
This woman is uniquely able to provide insight here, which a lot of the censorious attempts at CNs miss. In an investigation, motive is important, it is not uncommon for people to deceive & lie about their motive, especially those capable of such an act. Islamists can lie too. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(52-3-39) Author
2024-12-21 19:32:05
Her logic is fluid: - It is absurd to say his name indicates his radical Shia believes. - Taqiya doesn't work when you disbelieve in Islam or in his case - fighting some ex-muslims doesn't make him radical muslim - She didn't show any evidence him counseling ISIS. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(105-4-164) Author
2024-12-21 21:19:29
NNN. There is a clear difference in his English and Arabic posts [Link][Link][Link][Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(49-2-19) Author
2024-12-21 22:58:27
NNN "Jubilant Ice Magpie" Wikipedia is not a reliable source NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(36-3-28) Author
2024-12-22 00:04:14
While here points are logically sound and reasoned they lack credible evidence which will only present itself after a full investigation.Also her points could be of a personal bias because of her experiences of living in Iran which I believe could affect parts of her analysis. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(10-5-41) Author
2024-12-22 01:13:42
NNN. Almost all notes suggested here are not helpful. She presents a personal opinion. If you see some flaws in her logic, feel free to react in comments. Community notes should serve only for providing missing context or correcting factual claims. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(80-4-35) Author
2024-12-22 03:33:20
taqiyya is often distorted by anti-Muslim bigotry. In reality, it was a doctrine for Muslims to hide their faith when facing persecution. Also the terrorist here was anti-Muslim immigration to europe, anti-Islam, pro-AfD, pro-Musk, pro-Israel [Link][Link][Link][Link][Link][Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(172-3-163) Author
2024-12-22 04:11:49
NNN. Person is factually correct in stating that Taqqiya is a practice that allows Muslims to lie to advance broader Islamic agenda. Also if he was Islamophobe, he would have targeted Muslims, not Christians. [Link][Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(65-7-57) Author
2024-12-22 08:53:36
NNN - if he is anti Islam why did he drive into a Christmas market and not a mosque? NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(27-3-42) Author
2024-12-22 12:11:36
Maral Salmassi a native Iranian Music Producer+award-nominated artist tried to offer an explanation for the behavior of the Magdeburg-attacker.She does not use the simple narrative of Islamist versus anti-Islamist, but refers to the similarly deep conflict between Sunnis+Shiites. NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(17-2-28) Author
2024-12-22 19:20:52
Taqiyya is only permitted when muslims are under threat of violence for their faith. The attacker has no legitimate reason that he was under threat of violence for his belief even if he was believed to be muslim [Link][Link][Link][Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(39-3-30) Author
2024-12-23 10:51:47
Even in Shia teachings, Taqiyya is only used to protect oneself from persecution, not to commit terrorist acts. Hence, this is not Taqiyya. [Link] Also, he has expressed his anti-Islam stance on X for more than 8 years. [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(31-1-13) Author
2024-12-24 19:48:24
Taqiyya means to hide their one’s faith when facing persecution by non-Muslims, not murder [Link] This terrorist was anti-Islam, pro-AfD, pro-Israel, pro-Zionist Saudi dissident [Link][Link][Link][Link][Link][Link][Link] He was quiet when Alles Klar is heard and had a different voice profile [Link] NEEDS_MORE_RATINGS(3-0-5) Author